In the heart of the Castro is Finn Town Tavern. We went here. We ate here. I'm sure we liked it (sorry, way delayed post!). The food sure looks good!
Restaurant Club started in May 2005 with Julia, Gail, Dionne and Stephanie, who all take turns picking the restaurant of their choice. Three main rules: (1) the person choosing must pick a restaurant they've never been to; (2) ordering dessert is mandatory and (3) guests must be female. We're eating (and drinking) our way through San Francisco...